Surgery is expensive. There’s no sugarcoating it. Even a standard procedure is thousands of dollars in the United States. A knee replacement? Anywhere from $30,000 to $50,000. A C-section? Around $15,000 to $20,000. And if you don’t have great insurance, those numbers might seem impossible to meet.
But here’s the thing — you have more control over surgical costs than you realize. Hospitals and surgical centers do not operate like grocery stores selling apples for a set price. Costs differ vastly depending on where you go, how aggressively you negotiate, and what preparation you do before signing any contract.
This guide takes you through 12 tangible, actionable ways to save money on surgery. These tips are for those with insurance, without it, and everyone in between. Let’s dive in.
1. Shop Around as if You’re Making a Major Purchase
Few people spend more time finding the best price on a new TV than on surgery. That needs to change.
Surgical prices vary tremendously — as much as 300 percent or more — from one hospital in a city to another. The prices hospitals bill private insurers for the same procedure vary widely, according to a study by RAND Corporation.
How to Compare Surgery Prices
- Check fair prices in your area using tools like Healthcare Bluebook, FAIR Health, or ClearHealthCosts.
- Call numerous hospitals and surgical centers, asking for the “self-pay” or “cash pay” price.
- Request an itemized price list — hospitals now have to post their prices online, by law.
Do not assume that the most expensive option is necessarily the best. There isn’t always a correlation between quality and price.
2. If Possible, Choose an Ambulatory Surgery Center (ASC) Versus a Hospital
Here’s a little secret that many people don’t know: you don’t always have to have surgery in a major hospital.
Ambulatory Surgery Centers (ASCs) are outpatient facilities in which many routine surgeries are performed safely and at significantly lower costs. Think of procedures like:
- Cataract surgery
- Knee arthroscopy
- Hernia repair
- Colonoscopies
- Gallbladder removal
Why ASCs Cost Less
| Factor | Hospital | ASC |
|---|---|---|
| Overhead | High | Very low |
| Average savings vs. hospital | — | 45–60% lower |
| Infection risk | Higher | Lower |
| Wait times | Often longer | Usually shorter |
ASCs have lower overhead, fewer layers of staff, and specialize in certain procedures — making them more efficient and cost-effective.
Ask your surgeon whether your procedure can be performed at an ASC. Many surgeons work at both.
3. Speak to Your Surgeon Directly About Cost
This is jarring to many people. But doctors are more receptive to this conversation than you might think.
Your surgeon often has power over where your operation occurs and how it’s billed. Some surgeons will also discount their own fees for uninsured or underinsured patients.
What to Say
Try something like: “I’m paying out of pocket. Is there any room in your fee, or do you have a less expensive facility you can recommend?”
You may be taken aback by the answer. Most surgeons have a sliding scale, or can direct you to lower-cost options.
Also ask whether any pieces of the surgery can be made simpler or omitted from the plan without adversely impacting your outcome. Extras are sometimes added on to a procedure that aren’t strictly necessary.
4. Seek Out Multiple Opinions Before Going Under the Knife
Not all surgery is truly necessary. That sounds shocking, but it’s true.
Second opinions can change a diagnosis or treatment plan in as much as 30 percent of cases, studies have shown. Getting a second — or even third — opinion can spare you an unnecessary procedure altogether.
The Importance of a Proper Second Opinion
- Elective surgeries (joint replacements, back surgery, etc.)
- Cancer diagnoses and surgical recommendations
- Any surgery where the doctor tells you that you need it “soon but not right now”
Some insurance plans include second opinion consultations. Check your policy.
A second opinion also gives you peace of mind, and might lead to a different (and cheaper) approach even if you do need the surgery.
5. Be Strategic About Your Insurance — Understand Your Plan Inside and Out
Insurance is confusing. Yet being unaware of your plan could lead to big bills.
You need to understand these terms before any surgery:
| Term | What It Means |
|---|---|
| Deductible | What you pay before insurance kicks in |
| Out-of-pocket maximum | The most you’ll ever pay in a year |
| In-network vs. out-of-network | Huge cost difference — always confirm both your surgeon AND facility are in-network |
| Pre-authorization | Some surgeries require insurance approval first |
| Co-insurance | Your share of costs after meeting deductible |
The In-Network Trap
Here’s one sneaky thing that happens — your surgeon may well be in-network, but the anesthesiologist or the assistant surgeon might not be. That can lead to surprise bills.
Ask every single provider who will be in that operating room whether they take your insurance. Get it in writing if you can.
6. Time Your Surgery Around Your Deductible Year
It’s one of the smartest money moves that most people never consider.
Your insurance deductible resets every year — often on January 1st. If you’ve already met your deductible for the year, having surgery before December 31st means your insurance will pick up a much larger portion of the bill.
Example
Let’s say your deductible is $3,000 and you’ve paid $2,800 toward it by October. If you go into surgery in November, you only have $200 more to pay before insurance picks up the rest. Wait until January? You reset and owe the full $3,000 first.
Timing surgery right can save you a pile of money with zero extra work.
On the other hand, if you haven’t met your deductible yet and it’s early in the year, scheduling surgery early may make sense so that all follow-up care and physical therapy will also fall within the same deductible period.
7. Negotiate Your Medical Bills — Before and After Surgery
Here’s what a lot of people don’t know: medical bills are negotiable. Hospitals usually charge prices well above what they actually expect insurers to pay, which gets negotiated down. You can do the same.
For more guidance on navigating health care costs and financial planning around medical procedures, Global Health Financial offers practical resources to help patients make smarter financial decisions.
Before Surgery
- Request the hospital’s “charity care” or financial assistance application.
- Hospitals — particularly nonprofits — are legally required to provide financial assistance programs.
- Request a prompt-pay discount if you’re able to pay a lump sum.
After Surgery
- Ask for an itemized bill and check for errors. According to studies, as many as 80% of medical bills contain errors.
- Dispute anything that looks wrong.
- Call the billing department and simply ask: “Is there any way to lower this balance?”
- Offer to pay a reduced lump sum instead of a payment plan — many hospitals will accept 40–60 cents on the dollar.
Don’t be embarrassed. This is a common practice in health care finance.
8. Consider Medical Tourism For Non-Emergency Procedures
If you have a non-emergency elective procedure under consideration and you are not in imminent danger, medical tourism can save 50–80% compared with American prices.
Countries such as Mexico, Thailand, India, Costa Rica, and Turkey have internationally accredited hospitals where skilled surgeons trained in the U.S. or Europe perform procedures. According to the Medical Tourism Association, millions of Americans travel abroad each year to access quality care at a fraction of the cost.
Popular Procedures and Approximate International Savings
| Procedure | U.S. Average Cost | International Average | Savings |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hip replacement | $40,000 | $12,000–$18,000 | Up to 70% |
| Dental implants | $4,500/tooth | $900–$1,500/tooth | Up to 75% |
| LASIK eye surgery | $4,200 | $1,200–$2,000 | Up to 70% |
| Heart bypass | $123,000 | $20,000–$35,000 | Up to 75% |
Important Cautions
- Research accreditation — look for Joint Commission International (JCI) certified hospitals.
- Consider travel costs, recovery time, and any follow-up care when you return home.
- Medical tourism is best suited for non-emergency, elective procedures.
- Purchase medical travel insurance for added protection.
9. Apply for Financial Assistance Programs at the Hospital
All nonprofit hospitals in the United States are legally obligated to provide financial assistance — also known as charity care — to eligible patients.
A lot of people skip this, assuming they won’t qualify. But the income limits are frequently higher than you might think.
How to Apply
- Contact the billing department or financial counselor for the application.
- Collect the documents: proof of income, tax returns, bank statements.
- Apply before or soon after surgery.
- Check in regularly — these programs can lower or even zero out your bill.
Some hospitals completely write off costs for patients at or below 200–300% of the federal poverty level. Even if you make more than that, some assistance might still be available.
Don’t leave this money on the table.
10. Use a Health Savings Account (HSA) or Flexible Spending Account (FSA)
Use your HSA or FSA — if available to you through an employer plan or your own health plan — for surgery costs.
Why This Saves You Money
Both accounts allow you to set aside money before tax is taken out. If you’re in the 22% tax bracket, that means you save $1,100 on your taxes just by putting $5,000 into an HSA.
| Account | Who Can Use It | Rollover? | 2024 Contribution Limit |
|---|---|---|---|
| HSA | Must have high-deductible health plan | Yes, rolls over forever | $4,150 individual / $8,300 family |
| FSA | Most employer health plans | Limited rollover | $3,200 |
An HSA is particularly powerful because unused funds roll over each year forever and grow tax-free. A surgery fund can be built up over time.
If you know surgery is imminent, front-load your contributions.
11. Ask About Generic Anesthesia, Implants, and Supplies
This one surprises people. The brand of implant or surgical supply used in your procedure can vary costs drastically.
For example, if you’re getting a hip or knee replacement, there are name-brand implants and generic/equivalent implants that perform similarly but cost significantly less.
Questions to Ask Your Surgeon
- “Are there equivalent implants or devices that are cheaper?”
- “Is the brand of anesthesia medication flexible?”
- “Can we use a generic version of any products?”
Surgeons typically fall back on what they know best, and that’s not always the least expensive option. A straightforward conversation can steer you toward more affordable alternatives without sacrificing care.
Also ask whether you really need to stay overnight. Outpatient vs. inpatient billing can differ by thousands of dollars. If you can recover at home, it’s almost always less expensive to go home the same day.
12. Hire a Medical Billing Advocate
If all this sounds overwhelming — or you are already looking at a massive bill — a medical billing advocate can be a game changer.
These are professionals who negotiate with hospitals and insurance companies on your behalf. They know the billing codes, the common mistakes, and negotiation techniques that most patients never learn.
What a Medical Billing Advocate Does
- Checks your bill line by line for mistakes and overcharges
- Contests wrong charges with the hospital
- Negotiates reduced balances
- Helps with applying for financial assistance
- Communicates with your insurance company if claims were denied
What It Costs
Most advocates are paid on contingency — that is, they take a percentage (usually 25–35%) of the amount they save you. So if they save you $10,000, they get to keep $2,500 to $3,500. You still come out way ahead.
Look for advocates through the Patient Advocate Foundation, the Alliance of Claims Assistance Professionals, or by searching “medical billing advocate” in your area.
Quick Reference: Save on Surgery Checklist
| Step | Action | Potential Savings |
|---|---|---|
| Shop around | Compare prices at multiple facilities | 20–60% |
| Use an ASC | Use outpatient surgical center instead of hospital | 45–60% |
| Negotiate surgeon rates | Ask directly for lower fees | 10–30% |
| Get a second opinion | Avoid unnecessary surgery | Up to 100% |
| Stay in-network | Avoid out-of-network surprise bills | Thousands |
| Time your surgery | Schedule around your deductible year | Up to full deductible amount |
| Negotiate the bill | Dispute errors, request discounts | 20–80% |
| Medical tourism | Travel for elective procedures | 50–80% |
| Charity care | Apply for hospital assistance | Up to 100% |
| HSA/FSA | Pay with pre-tax dollars | 22–37% (tax savings) |
| Ask about generics | Request lower-cost implants/supplies | 10–40% |
| Hire an advocate | Professional bill negotiation | 25–50% of bill |
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Is it actually possible to negotiate with a hospital over surgery? Yes, absolutely. Negotiation is a constant in hospital billing departments. Applying for a payment reduction, asking for a discount, or offering to pay less in one lump sum — these are standard practices that can leave you owing substantially less than initially billed.
Q: Is medical tourism safe? For planned elective procedures, medical tourism at JCI-accredited hospitals can be very safe. The key is to do due diligence on the facility, the surgeon’s qualifications, and to have a plan for aftercare when you return home.
Q: What if I just cannot afford surgery at all? Begin with the hospital charity care application. Also investigate Medicaid if you’re eligible, community health centers, and the Patient Advocate Foundation’s co-pay relief programs. Many people qualify for more help than they think.
Q: Will my doctor be offended by a second opinion? Rarely. The vast majority of ethical doctors welcome a second opinion, especially in the case of serious procedures. If a doctor acts offended or pressures you to forgo a second opinion, that itself is a red flag.
Q: Can I use my HSA to pay for surgery if I’ve already had it? Yes — as long as the surgery was performed after you established your HSA account, you can reimburse yourself from HSA funds even later. Keep your receipts.
Q: What is an itemized hospital bill? It is a detailed breakdown of each charge on your bill — every pill, every supply, every fee. You have the right to request one. Errors are very common, so always check it carefully.
Q: How can I find a reputable medical billing advocate? Look into the Patient Advocate Foundation (patientadvocate.org), the Alliance of Claims Assistance Professionals, or ask your state’s insurance commissioner’s office for a referral.
The Bottom Line
The cost of surgery in America is broken. But you are not doomed to be a victim of the system.
Shopping around, going to an ambulatory surgery center, negotiating your bill, using your HSA, or applying for charity care — every single one of these steps puts money back in your pocket.
You are not required to attempt all 12 at the same time. Begin with two or three that fit your situation. Even a single well-timed phone call to a hospital billing department can save you thousands of dollars.
The most important thing? Do not assume that the first number you see is final. It almost never is.
Your health is worth protecting. So is your financial future. Now you can address both with these 12 ways to save on surgery.
Leave a Reply